ui/src/game/Game.svelte

@@ -1107,7 +1107,15 @@
     if (!view) return '';
     const me = view.game.seats[view.seat];
     if (me?.isWinner) return t('game.won');
-    return view.game.seats.some((s) => s.isWinner) ? t('game.lost') : t('game.tied');
+    if (view.game.endReason === 'aborted') return t('game.tied'); // an abort is a draw for everyone
+    const myScore = me?.score ?? 0;
+    // A declared winner (incl. by resignation) that is not me, or anyone who scored higher → a loss.
+    if (view.game.seats.some((s) => s.isWinner) || view.game.seats.some((s) => !s.resigned && s.score > myScore)) {
+      return t('game.lost');
+    }
+    // No one above me and no declared winner: a tie for the lead is a (shared) win; only an
+    // all-level finish is a draw.
+    return view.game.seats.filter((s) => !s.resigned).every((s) => s.score === myScore) ? t('game.tied') : t('game.won');
   }
 
   // The finished-game export offers two formats — the GCG file and the server-rendered PNG

ui/src/lib/result.test.ts

@@ -75,6 +75,18 @@ describe('resultBadge', () => {
     const second = game([seat(0, 'me', 300), seat(1, 'a', 400, true), seat(2, 'b', 200), seat(3, 'c', 100)]);
     expect(resultBadge(second, 'me')).toEqual({ key: 'result.place2', emoji: '🥈' });
   });
+
+  it('tie for the lead (3-4p): a shared victory for the leaders, a placed finish for those below', () => {
+    // The reported case, viewer-side: two seats tie for the lead (-8), one is last (-14) — no single
+    // winner(), so this must NOT read as a full draw for everyone.
+    expect(resultBadge(game([seat(0, 'me', -8), seat(1, 'a', -14), seat(2, 'b', -8)]), 'me')).toEqual({ key: 'result.victory', emoji: '🏆' });
+    expect(resultBadge(game([seat(0, 'x', -8), seat(1, 'me', -14), seat(2, 'b', -8)]), 'me')).toEqual({ key: 'result.place3', emoji: '🥉' });
+  });
+
+  it('an aborted game reads as a draw for everyone, whatever the scores', () => {
+    const g = { ...game([seat(0, 'me', 50), seat(1, 'a', 30)]), endReason: 'aborted' };
+    expect(resultBadge(g, 'me')).toEqual({ key: 'result.draw', emoji: '🏅' });
+  });
 });
 
 describe('seatMedal', () => {

ui/src/lib/result.ts

@@ -9,6 +9,13 @@ export interface ResultBadge {
   emoji: string;
 }
 
+/** placeBadge maps a 1-based finishing rank to its label + medal (2nd is a defeat in a duel). */
+function placeBadge(rank: number, players: number): ResultBadge {
+  if (rank === 2) return players === 2 ? { key: 'result.defeat', emoji: '🥈' } : { key: 'result.place2', emoji: '🥈' };
+  if (rank === 3) return { key: 'result.place3', emoji: '🥉' };
+  return { key: 'result.place4', emoji: '🏅' };
+}
+
 export function resultBadge(game: GameView, myId: string): ResultBadge {
   const me = game.seats.find((s) => s.accountId === myId);
 
@@ -19,16 +26,24 @@ export function resultBadge(game: GameView, myId: string): ResultBadge {
   }
 
   if (me?.isWinner) return { key: 'result.victory', emoji: '🏆' };
-  if (!game.seats.some((s) => s.isWinner)) return { key: 'result.draw', emoji: '🏅' };
 
-  // Someone else won and it is not me, so I did not win — even when scores are level (a
-  // win by resignation or timeout can leave the winner at or below my score). The winner
-  // takes rank 1; place me among the remaining seats by score, starting at rank 2.
-  const ahead = game.seats.filter((s) => !s.isWinner && s.accountId !== myId && s.score > (me?.score ?? 0)).length;
-  const rank = 2 + ahead;
-  if (rank === 2) return game.players === 2 ? { key: 'result.defeat', emoji: '🥈' } : { key: 'result.place2', emoji: '🥈' };
-  if (rank === 3) return { key: 'result.place3', emoji: '🥉' };
-  return { key: 'result.place4', emoji: '🏅' };
+  // No single winner: a tie for the lead, a full draw, or an aborted game. An abort or an all-level
+  // finish is a draw; a tie for the lead is a SHARED victory for the top scorers, and a placed finish
+  // for those below. (winner() is -1 on ANY tie for the lead, so isWinner alone cannot tell a
+  // three-way "two share first, one is last" apart from a genuine draw — the reported bug.)
+  if (!game.seats.some((s) => s.isWinner)) {
+    const myScore = me?.score ?? 0;
+    const higher = game.seats.filter((s) => !s.resigned && s.score > myScore).length;
+    const allLevel = game.seats.filter((s) => !s.resigned).every((s) => s.score === myScore);
+    if (game.endReason === 'aborted' || (higher === 0 && allLevel)) return { key: 'result.draw', emoji: '🏅' };
+    return higher === 0 ? { key: 'result.victory', emoji: '🏆' } : placeBadge(1 + higher, game.players);
+  }
+
+  // A winner exists but it is not me — even when scores are level (a win by resignation or timeout
+  // can leave the winner at or below my score). The winner takes rank 1; place me among the remaining
+  // (non-resigned) seats by score, starting at rank 2.
+  const ahead = game.seats.filter((s) => !s.isWinner && !s.resigned && s.accountId !== myId && s.score > (me?.score ?? 0)).length;
+  return placeBadge(2 + ahead, game.players);
 }
 
 /**